Vegan Controversy: Joaquin Phoenix's Struggle and the Horseback Riding Dilemma in the Film ‘‘Napoleon’’

Vegan Activism

Dec 07, 2023

In the world of film, where storytelling intertwines with ethical considerations, the clash between artistic choices and vegan principles has come to the forefront. The latest controversy surrounding Ridley Scott's Napoleon, starring Joaquin Phoenix as the iconic military commander, unveils the challenges faced by the vegan actor in maintaining his ethical stance while participating in the creative process.

‘‘In the world of entertainment and specifically within the film industry, the ‘Napoleon’ movie controversy illuminates the shifting contours of veganism. Technological strides empower filmmakers to weave captivating tales without compromising animal welfare. Joaquin Phoenix's odyssey triggers reflections at the crossroads of ethics and art, instigating vital discussions in the vegan community on forgiveness, understanding, and the unwavering pursuit of cruelty-free filmmaking.’’

Vegan Fashion Triumph

The film's costume designer, David Crossman, found himself in a dilemma when tasked with creating Napoleon's iconic hats without using animal products. Phoenix's commitment to a vegan lifestyle prompted the need for cruelty-free alternatives. Crossman's solution? A plant-based fabric derived from tree bark in Uganda provides not only an animal-friendly option but also adds a unique texture to the hats. This triumph highlights the feasibility of incorporating vegan choices even in seemingly traditional aspects of filmmaking.

The Horseback Riding Controversy

Earlier this year, a still from Napoleon ignited a heated debate within the vegan community as it captured Joaquin Phoenix riding a horse. While the actor has not directly addressed the image, his past statements reveal a conflicted sentiment about riding horses. In 2018's The Sisters Brothers, Phoenix admitted to feeling remorse when engaging in equestrian scenes. Vegan advocacy group PETA seized the opportunity to call for an end to the use of live animals in film, emphasizing the availability of modern alternatives like CGI.

Is Horse Riding Vegan?

The question of whether horseback riding aligns with vegan principles is a complex and divisive one. Traditionalists argue that well-treated horses, especially those involved in film, face minimal harm. However ethical vegans argue that using horses or any animal for entertainment purposes or any use is not vegan. PETA contends that even with precautions, the inherent risk of injury or death remains.

Joaquin Phoenix's Dilemma

For Joaquin Phoenix, being part of a film that involves horseback riding raises ethical concerns. The actor, known for his dedication to animal rights and veganism, faces a dilemma as he navigates the artistic demands of his craft against his values. The vegan community, in turn, grapples with the question of whether forgiveness is warranted in such instances.

Can Joaquin Phoenix Be Forgiven?

I believe that the path to forgiveness within the vegan community involves acknowledging the complexities of the film industry and the compromises actors may make to pursue their craft. While some may argue that Phoenix's involvement in scenes depicting horseback riding contradicts vegan principles, others may recognize that the actor's influence in sparking discussions about the ethical treatment of animals in the entertainment business strongly mitigates the negative impact of this controversy.

Conclusion

The Napoleon controversy sheds light on the evolving landscape of veganism in the film industry. As technology advances, filmmakers are presented with opportunities to create captivating narratives without compromising animal welfare. Joaquin Phoenix's journey prompts reflection on the intersection of ethics and art, sparking important conversations within the vegan community about forgiveness, understanding, and the continuous pursuit of cruelty-free filmmaking.

The Vegan's Voice

Discussion about this post