A Comprehensive History of the New Thought Movement
The New Thought (or Higher Thought) Movement represents a fascinating and transformative chapter in the history of Western spirituality. Emerging in the 19th century, this movement has left an indelible mark on modern self-help philosophies, the culture of positive thinking, and even aspects of contemporary spiritual practices. Its influence can be seen not only in religious and philosophical circles but also in the broader social and cultural fabric of the 20th and 21st centuries. This article dives into the rich history, key figures, and enduring legacy of the New Thought Movement, offering readers a comprehensive understanding of its origins, evolution, and impact on modern life.
Origins of the New Thought Movement
19th Century Beginnings: The Cultural and Philosophical Context
The New Thought Movement was born in the intellectually fertile soil of 19th-century America, a time characterized by rapid social change, spiritual exploration, and philosophical innovation. The early 1800s were a period of great upheaval and transformation, marked by the rise of industrialization, the spread of democratic ideals, and a growing interest in alternative religious and philosophical systems. Against this backdrop, New Thought emerged as a response to the increasingly rigid and dogmatic nature of traditional religious institutions.
Central to the intellectual environment that gave rise to New Thought was the influence of transcendentalism. This philosophical movement, led by thinkers like Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau, emphasized the inherent goodness of people and nature, the importance of self-reliance, and the primacy of the individual soul over external religious authorities. Transcendentalism’s focus on the inner life and the power of personal intuition laid the groundwork for New Thought’s emphasis on the mind’s ability to shape reality.
Phineas Parkhurst Quimby: The Father of New Thought
One of the most influential figures in the early development of New Thought was Phineas Parkhurst Quimby, a clockmaker from Maine who turned to healing after suffering from a chronic illness. Quimby’s journey into the world of healing began after he experienced relief from his ailment through the power of belief and suggestion. Convinced that the mind played a crucial role in physical health, Quimby began to develop his own theories on the connection between thoughts and well-being.
Quimby’s ideas were revolutionary for their time. He posited that many physical ailments were the result of erroneous beliefs and that by changing one’s thoughts, one could achieve healing. This concept, which he referred to as “the Science of Health,” laid the foundation for what would later become the central tenet of New Thought: the idea that our thoughts create our reality.
Quimby’s influence extended to many of his contemporaries, most notably Mary Baker Eddy, who would go on to found Christian Science. Although Eddy eventually distanced her teachings from Quimby’s, the basic principles she learned from him—particularly the idea that sickness is a mental error that can be corrected through right thinking—remained central to her philosophy.
Development and Spread of New Thought
Expansion in the Early 20th Century
As the 19th century gave way to the 20th, New Thought began to grow and diversify, evolving into a broad movement with many different branches and interpretations. Various organizations, churches, and publications sprang up, each promoting its own version of New Thought principles. This period saw the rise of several key figures who would shape the movement’s development and help spread its teachings across the United States and beyond.
Emma Curtis Hopkins, often referred to as the “teacher of teachers,” was one such figure. A former student of Mary Baker Eddy, Hopkins eventually parted ways with Christian Science to develop her own teachings, which she called “Scientific Christian Mental Practice.” Hopkins went on to train many of the movement’s future leaders, including Charles and Myrtle Fillmore, who would later found the Unity School of Christianity, one of the most enduring and influential New Thought organizations.
Another significant contributor to the movement during this period was Ernest Holmes, who founded the Religious Science movement (also known as the Science of Mind). Holmes’s teachings emphasized the practical application of spiritual principles to improve everyday life, a hallmark of New Thought philosophy. His book, The Science of Mind, remains a foundational text for those studying New Thought and continues to be widely read and respected in spiritual circles.
The Core Philosophy of New Thought
The central philosophy of New Thought revolves around the idea that our thoughts and beliefs have a direct and powerful influence on our lives. This concept is often summed up in the phrase “thoughts are things,” which encapsulates the belief that our mental attitudes and thought patterns shape our experiences and realities. According to New Thought teachings, by cultivating positive thoughts and focusing on what we desire, we can attract those things into our lives—whether they be health, wealth, happiness, or success.
This focus on the power of positive thinking and the mind’s ability to influence reality distinguishes New Thought from other spiritual movements of its time. While many religious and philosophical systems emphasize the importance of belief or faith, New Thought uniquely combines these with an emphasis on mental discipline and personal responsibility. The movement teaches that individuals have the power to change their circumstances by changing their thoughts, a message that has resonated with countless people seeking to improve their lives.
New Thought also places a strong emphasis on the idea of divine immanence—the belief that God or the divine is present in all things and that each person is an expression of this divine presence. This concept leads to a more personalized and less hierarchical approach to spirituality, where individuals are encouraged to seek their own direct experience of the divine rather than relying on intermediaries such as clergy or religious institutions.
Influence on Modern Spirituality and Self-Help
New Thought’s Impact on Popular Culture
The ideas and principles of the New Thought Movement have had a profound influence on popular culture, particularly in the realm of self-help and personal development. Throughout the 20th century, New Thought concepts like positive thinking, affirmations, and the law of attraction began to permeate mainstream culture, often through the medium of self-help literature.
One of the most famous proponents of New Thought principles was Norman Vincent Peale, whose 1952 book The Power of Positive Thinking became a bestseller and introduced millions to the idea that maintaining a positive mindset could lead to success and happiness. Peale’s work, which drew heavily on New Thought ideas, popularized the concept of positive thinking and made it accessible to a broad audience.
Similarly, Louise Hay’s book You Can Heal Your Life, first published in 1984, brought New Thought principles to a new generation of readers. Hay, who was influenced by the teachings of Ernest Holmes and other New Thought leaders, emphasized the connection between mental attitudes and physical health. Her work on affirmations and self-healing has had a lasting impact on the self-help movement and continues to inspire individuals seeking to improve their well-being.
The Law of Attraction and the New Age Movement
One of the most significant and enduring legacies of the New Thought Movement is the concept of the law of attraction, which asserts that like attracts like and that by focusing on positive or negative thoughts, individuals can bring positive or negative experiences into their lives. This idea, which is deeply rooted in New Thought philosophy, has become a cornerstone of the New Age movement and has gained widespread popularity in recent decades.
The law of attraction was brought to mainstream attention in 2006 with the release of the book and film The Secret, which presented the idea as a universal principle that could be harnessed to achieve personal success and fulfillment. The success of The Secret sparked renewed interest in New Thought teachings and introduced a new generation to the movement’s ideas.
While the law of attraction has been embraced by many as a powerful tool for personal transformation, it has also been the subject of criticism and debate. Some critics argue that the concept oversimplifies complex issues and can lead to a form of “victim-blaming,” where individuals are held responsible for their own misfortunes due to their thoughts. Others have raised concerns about the commercialization of New Thought ideas and the potential for exploitation in the self-help industry.
Criticism and Controversy
Philosophical and Theological Critiques
Despite its widespread appeal, the New Thought Movement has not been without its critics. From its inception, New Thought has faced opposition from traditional religious institutions, which have often viewed its teachings as unorthodox or even heretical. The movement’s emphasis on the power of the individual mind to shape reality has been seen by some as a challenge to more established religious doctrines, which typically emphasize the role of divine will and grace in determining the course of human life.
One of the main theological critiques of New Thought is its approach to the problem of evil and suffering. Critics argue that by attributing all experiences—positive and negative—to an individual’s thoughts, New Thought can lead to a superficial understanding of suffering and may fail to account for the complexities of human experience. This critique is particularly relevant in the context of physical illness, where the suggestion that a person’s thoughts are responsible for their condition can be seen as dismissive of the very real challenges faced by those who are sick.
The Commercialization of New Thought Ideas
Another area of controversy surrounding New Thought is the commercialization of its ideas. Over the years, New Thought principles have been repackaged and sold in various forms, from self-help books and seminars to online courses and coaching programs. While this has helped to spread the movement’s teachings to a wider audience, it has also raised concerns about the commodification of spirituality and the potential for exploitation.
Some critics argue that the commercialization of New Thought has led to the oversimplification of its teachings, reducing complex philosophical ideas to easily digestible sound bites or catchphrases. This, in turn, can create unrealistic expectations and place undue pressure on individuals to achieve success or happiness through sheer force of will. Additionally, the focus on material success and personal gain that often accompanies the commercialization of New Thought can sometimes overshadow the movement’s deeper spiritual and philosophical dimensions. This has led to criticisms that New Thought, in its popularized form, may encourage a form of “spiritual materialism,” where the pursuit of wealth, success, and personal fulfillment becomes the primary goal, rather than a deeper connection with the divine or an understanding of one’s place in the universe.
However, it is important to note that not all proponents of New Thought subscribe to this materialistic interpretation. Many within the movement emphasize the importance of inner growth, compassion, and service to others as central to the practice of New Thought principles. These advocates argue that while material success may be a byproduct of positive thinking and spiritual alignment, it should not be the sole focus. Instead, they encourage a more balanced approach that integrates personal development with a commitment to the greater good.
The Legacy and Continuing Relevance of New Thought
Ongoing Influence on Spiritual Practices and Communities
Today, the New Thought Movement continues to thrive, with numerous organizations, churches, and communities dedicated to teaching and practicing its principles. The Unity Church, Religious Science, and the Church of Divine Science are among the most prominent New Thought organizations, each offering a unique interpretation of the movement’s teachings. These communities provide a space for individuals to explore the power of positive thinking, meditation, and spiritual healing in a supportive and nurturing environment.
In addition to these established organizations, New Thought principles have found a new audience through digital platforms and online communities. The internet has enabled the spread of New Thought ideas to a global audience, allowing individuals from diverse backgrounds to connect, share experiences, and learn from one another. This digital evolution has helped to keep New Thought relevant in the 21st century, as people seek out new ways to navigate the complexities of modern life.
One of the key reasons for New Thought’s enduring appeal is its adaptability. The movement’s core principles—such as the power of the mind, the importance of positive thinking, and the belief in a benevolent universe—are flexible enough to be applied in a variety of contexts. Whether individuals are seeking personal healing, professional success, or spiritual enlightenment, New Thought offers a framework that can be tailored to their specific needs and goals.
The Enduring Impact on Personal Development and Self-Help
The legacy of the New Thought Movement is perhaps most visible in the ongoing popularity of personal development and self-help literature. The principles of New Thought have become deeply embedded in the self-help genre, influencing countless books, seminars, and programs that aim to empower individuals to take control of their lives and achieve their full potential.
Authors such as Wayne Dyer, Deepak Chopra, and Tony Robbins have all been influenced by New Thought principles, and their work has reached millions of people worldwide. These authors, along with many others, have helped to popularize concepts such as affirmations, visualization, and the law of attraction, all of which are rooted in New Thought philosophy.
Moreover, New Thought’s emphasis on the mind-body connection and the role of consciousness in shaping reality has also had a significant impact on the field of psychology and wellness. Techniques such as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and mindfulness meditation, which focus on changing thought patterns to improve mental and emotional well-being, share common ground with New Thought teachings. This overlap has led to a greater acceptance of New Thought ideas within the broader field of mental health and wellness.
The Future of New Thought in a Changing World
As we look to the future, it is clear that the New Thought Movement will continue to evolve and adapt to meet the needs of a changing world. The challenges of the 21st century—such as environmental degradation, social inequality, and global health crises—require new approaches to personal and collective well-being. In this context, New Thought’s emphasis on the power of individual consciousness and the interconnectedness of all life offers a valuable perspective.
There is also a growing recognition of the need for a more holistic approach to spirituality, one that integrates personal development with social responsibility. Within the New Thought community, there is an increasing emphasis on the importance of addressing not only individual well-being but also the well-being of society as a whole. This shift reflects a broader trend within the spiritual and self-help movements towards greater awareness of social justice and environmental sustainability.
Furthermore, as the New Thought Movement continues to expand its reach through digital platforms, there is an opportunity to engage with new audiences and explore innovative ways of teaching and practicing its principles. Virtual communities, online courses, and digital media offer new possibilities for connecting with people around the world and making New Thought teachings accessible to a wider audience.
Conclusion
The New Thought (Higher Thought) Movement has had a profound and lasting impact on modern spirituality, personal development, and popular culture. From its origins in the 19th century as a response to the dogmatic constraints of traditional religion, New Thought has grown into a diverse and influential movement that continues to inspire and empower individuals across the globe.
Through its emphasis on the power of the mind, positive thinking, and the belief in a benevolent universe, New Thought has offered countless people a pathway to personal growth, healing, and spiritual fulfillment. While the movement has faced its share of criticism and controversy, its core principles remain relevant and resonant in today’s fast-paced, often challenging world.
As we move forward, the New Thought Movement is likely to continue evolving, finding new ways to address the needs of individuals and society in an ever-changing world. Whether through traditional organizations, digital platforms, or new forms of spiritual practice, the principles of New Thought will undoubtedly continue to inspire and guide those who seek to harness the power of their thoughts to create a better, more fulfilling life.
In the end, the enduring appeal of the New Thought Movement lies in its simple yet profound message: that each of us has the power to shape our reality through the thoughts we think and the beliefs we hold. This message, rooted in the belief in human potential and the interconnectedness of all life, remains as relevant today as it was over a century ago.
Author’s website
Recommended: The Reality Revolution